My local public library has an excellent graphic novel section, but there’s an awful lot of terrible stuff there as well. I thought I’d try some brief reviews, because a lot of people living in Wellington who are interested in comics and graphic novels may not realise this resource exists. So all the books mentioned are available for loan -which is good when you consider that a US$17 (NZ$26) graphic novel can cost NZ$50 (US$33) by the time it gets here.
Clyde Fans Book 1 by Seth
Drawn & Quarterly 2004
Seth fans know what to expect –Clyde Fans is a beautifully designed book leaden with quiet desperation. The first chapter features the retired son of the founder of a defunct fan company as he potters around the old premises, having breakfast, taking a bath, moving from room to room of the company and pointlessly rearranging old stock while relating the entire history of the company and telling old salesman jokes in a monologue that would make an excellent one-act play. He also tells of his agoraphobic older brother Simon and his withdrawal from public life. The second chapter skips back forty years to 1957, when Simon disastrously attempts a sales tour of a small town and fails every challenge. Reprinted from Palookaville, the stories are technically superb, but personally Seth has always left me cold. The duotone illustrations are more emotionally involved than the sterile precision of Chris Ware, but the emotions are still all so sad. Brief one-panel moments of joy exist only to be crushed. It’s taken seven years to collect this first book, so don’t expect the second any time soon.









